27 Easy Thanksgiving Pie Recipes And Ideas - Food.com (2024)

recipe

Double Layer Pumpkin Pie

"Great pumpkin pie and cheesecake dessert. It's the perfect recipe for this season and for Thanksgiving as well!"

-Jonathan Melendez

recipe

No-Bake Creamy Pumpkin Pie

"Totally perfect. Creamy and sweet and ADDICTING! I don't really love the thickness of traditional pumpkin pie so this was a refreshing departure."

-willamettevalleygirl

recipe

Old-Fashioned Buttermilk Pie

"The family was fighting over pieces of this pie at Thanksgiving. My only complaint is that I didn't make enough!"

-SuzTheQ

recipe

White Chocolate Cheesecake Pie

"I made this for Thanksgiving and it was a hit! I’m making it again for Christmas Eve. It’s very easy and very fast."

-Gemini1972

recipe

Mississippi Mud Pie

"My in-laws went nuts over this at Thanksgiving! I've now been commissioned by my sister-in-law to make this once a month!"

-Zanni

recipe

10-Minute Lime Pie

"This recipe has all the flavors and satisfaction of a key lime pie, but with only a quarter of the work and time. The crackers also give the pie a delicious saltiness."

-Liza at Food.com

recipe

Triple-Layer Pumpkin Cheesecake Pie

"The layers of this pie were perfect. It was just so good."

-Lisa Vargas

recipe

Vanilla Cream Pie

"This pie was so creamy and delicious! It got rave reviews from the whole family."

-cherir

recipe

"Wonderful recipe! Instead of milk, I used coconut milk and cream and then added a couple teaspoons of coconut extract. It was so easy to make but had that great homemade taste!"

-JOY1998

recipe

Fruit co*cktail Pie

"I made this pie for Thanksgiving and we all gave it 5 stars. Each delicious bite had a different fruity taste."

-MalaysianGal

recipe

Snappy Apple Pie

"This apple pie comes together in a snap — thus, the recipe title. It uses refrigerated pie crust and makes two pies. McCormick has a similar recipe, but I changed some things to make it to our liking."

-Lainey6605

recipe

Easy as Pumpkin Pie

"I really love this! It's delicious and easy, and has the perfect amount of spices. It took me only five minutes to put it together."

-cotoncandy

recipe

Bakery-Style Coconut Cream Pie

"I'm never going to buy a coconut cream pie from a bakery again. This was so delicious, I couldn't believe that I made it."

-Pale Rose

recipe

Oatmeal Raisin Cookie Pie

"We used a graham cracker crust and substituted Craisins for the raisins and it was SO good. So, so, so, so good — and very rich. I'm a big oatmeal raisin cookie fan, so this was right up my alley!"

-CandyTX

recipe

Banana Cream Pie

"Easy to make and tastes great! Topped it with 'Never Weep' Whipped Cream and used banana cream pudding dry mix in the topping for extra flavor."

-Jessica Hoylman

recipe

Peanut Butter Pie

"This is my go-to recipe for potlucks and dinner parties. It takes only 10 minutes to put together, and the topping options are endless."

-pewpew1982

recipe

Louisiana Pecan Pie

"This simple and delicious pecan pie will win over those who have never liked pecan pie before — take me, for example!"

-Leslulu

recipe

Apple Mini Tarts

"These are excellent! It is like having an apple pie without the work. I will be making these for the holidays rather than a whole pie. There will definitely not be any leftovers with these."

-AZPARZYCH

recipe

Mashed Sweet Potato Pie

Almost as easy as it is delectable, this silky sweet potato pie is a dream to make: Just mix baked sweet potatoes with staple ingredients like sugar and spices, then bake in a 9-inch pie shell.

recipe

No-Bake Maple Syrup Pie

"I love this pie. It's simple and so delicious. Everyone loves it. It's delightful served warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream."

-jenleighd

recipe

Turtle Pie

"This pie is heavenly! It improves with age and refrigeration. It's a snap to make, especially when you use a premade crust."

-sleepycat

recipe

Sugar Pie

"I made this pie for Thanksgiving so that we could have something a bit different from the usual pumpkin or apple pie. It was very well received!"

-Sydney Mike

recipe

Easy-Peasy Lemon-Squeezy Pie

"This recipe is super easy! I was able to throw it together fairly quickly and it tasted very good."

-SmartMomsSave

recipe

Cherry-O Cream Pie

"I've been making this pie for over 40 years! The filling is out of this world — so rich and creamy! You can use any pie topping on it, so don't limit yourself to just cherries."

-Bobbie

recipe

Chocolate Silk Pie

"This chocolate pie is sinfully rich without being overly sweet. It is a perfect dessert to serve to guests because it is so simple to prepare."

-Chef Buggsy Mate

recipe

Chocolate Chip Pie

"This pie is really great! It is thick, chocolatey and wonderfully sweet. It has a comforting taste that brought back memories of my childhood."

-Lalaloula

recipe

Canadian Brown Sugar Pie

"This pie was easy to whip together and a huge crowd-pleaser! Among our pie smorgasbord, this particular pie completely disappeared."

-chefyl